The big lie about LED lighting : Page 2 of 2

December 31, 2014 //By Scott Elder
The big lie about LED lighting
Scott Elder, principal engineer with Linear Technology discusses why LED lighting fails earlier than consumers might expect.


After a quick look around my 2,200-sq.-ft. house, I counted about 50 light bulbs. Once again, applying the product rule, the incandescent lamp failure rate inside my house should be about 1 out of 200. And the LED lamp failure rate should be about 1 out of 4! A 25% failure rate is ridiculous for a product that costs $10 or more and does nothing more than a product that costs 50 cents.


Perhaps a wiser engineer more skilled than I in the area of reliability would take issue with my 100-ppm failure rate. But doesn't it make sense that an offline power controller with nearly 100 components will have a higher failure rate than a system with 1 component? But no one ever talks about that. We are always told to compare the tungsten lifetime of 1,000 hours against the LED lifetime that is claimed equivalent to the lifetime of the family pet, or something close to that.


According to my wife, who is not an engineer, she purchased nine LED lamps for the kitchen and back porch over a period of one year, from three different manufacturers, and paid on average about $45 each. Out of the nine, and after two years, one by one they all started to fail. As of this blog, seven of the nine are dead.


I did a further reliability analysis on, looking at the ratings for LED lamps. Out of 400 reviews, 25 people gave a popular $10 LED lamp a rating of one. I started reading through the one-star reviews and virtually everyone who scored the lamp as a one claimed their score was because the lamps failed very quickly.


Even most of the 18 people who scored the lamp a two did so because of failure. I wonder how many of the five-star ratings would still be five stars after two years.


I've been designing LED circuits for years now. My first circuit was for a stadium sized LED TV and more recently battery powered lamps and backlighting for TVs and laptop computers. It would be disingenuous of me to claim that all LED lighting is useless. There are many great applications for LED lighting. But replacing a one-element off line circuit is not one of them.


Scott Elder, principal engineer with Linear Technology, is a 28-year veteran of analog IC design and the named inventors on 16 patents, all in the field of precision analog signal processing, power management, RF CMOS and LED drivers.


This article first appeared on EE Times' Planet Analog website.


Related links and articles:


News articles:


A tale of two thermostats: Nest teardown


OLED to compete with LED lighting by 2016


LED lighting: unintended effects in public lighting


Copenhagen starts smart LED lighting experiment



Vous êtes certain ?

Si vous désactivez les cookies, vous ne pouvez plus naviguer sur le site.

Vous allez être rediriger vers Google.